Rankings do not measure what you promised
Oxford has held the top spot in THE for 11 years; MIT, for 15 in QS. Two number ones at the same time, 17 indicators, and one notable absence: what your ethos promises is not in the table.

Gabriel Serrano

Cover image generated with artificial intelligence.
On September 30, Times Higher Education published its world university rankings. Oxford took first place for the eleventh consecutive year, edging out the runner-up, MIT, by a mere tenth of a point. Three months earlier, in June, QS had released its own: MIT was first, for the fifteenth straight year. Read that again. For more than a decade, the world has had two "best universities in the world" at the same time, each proclaimed by a different league table, and no one seems to find it odd.
This is not a scandal; it is a matter of definition. Two simultaneous champions are possible only if each table is measuring a different sport. And that is precisely what is happening: a ranking does not photograph reality; it first decides which slice of reality will count as reality, and then measures it impeccably. The pertinent question, for anyone leading a university or entrusting a child to one, is not who comes in first. It is what the table was actually measuring when it made that call.
Seventeen Indicators and a Conspicuous Absence
THE's methodology is public and warrants a careful reading, as it is a far more honest document than the public discourse surrounding its results. Seventeen indicators, grouped into five pillars: research quality, accounting for 30% of the overall score; research environment, 29%; teaching, 29.5%; international outlook, 7.5%; and industry engagement, 4%.
Now look closely at the pillar labeled "teaching." Of those 29.5 points, 15 stem from a reputation survey: tens of thousands of academics worldwide pointing out which institutions they perceive as prestigious. The remainder consists of administrative ratios: staff-to-student ratios, doctorates awarded per graduate, and institutional income per academic staff member. Combine the system's two prestige surveys—teaching and research—and an exact third of the overall score, 33%, rests entirely on reputation: more than 69,000 responses to the question of whom you admire. Merely to be considered for inclusion, an institution must have published a thousand indexed papers over five years. Yet among all seventeen indicators, there is not a single one—not one—that measures what takes place inside a classroom, or how a student is transformed between matriculation and commencement.
This is not a design flaw; it is the design itself. THE analyzes 188 million citations across nearly 20 million publications; it is a formidable apparatus for assessing research output and academic prestige. What it is not, nor purports to be, is a measure of education. The subtitle of the very article in which THE presented its findings conceded this with admirable candor: reputational luster, it suggested, continues to shelter the usual suspects.
The Spanish Fine Print
In the June edition of QS, 24 of the 38 Spanish universities previously featured dropped in the rankings. Spain's top-ranked institution appeared at 165th place. If one reads the table as one would read a report card, the conclusion appears alarming: the entire country is declining. But consider the matter calmly: do you truly believe that the quality of instruction across two out of three Spanish campuses deteriorated over the course of twelve months? What actually transpired is both simpler and far less dramatic: the table is relative; other university systems publish more and carry greater weight each year, and in a volume-driven race, running at a steady pace means falling behind. The descent does not reflect your classrooms; it reflects the nature of the race.
The revealing truth is that the most rigorous Spanish assessment tool reached this conclusion long ago. The CYD Ranking, developed by the CYD Foundation, encompasses 82 universities—public and private, representing 93% of the system—and evaluates six dimensions, including one that neither THE nor QS addresses: graduate employability. Furthermore, it explicitly renounces the podium. Its website states this unequivocally: "we do not construct a ranking to determine which university holds first, second, or third place." Instead, it presents performance tiers by dimension, allowing stakeholders to tailor comparisons to their specific inquiries. The podium, as it turns out, is not an imperative of measurement; it is an editorial choice made by whoever publishes the table.
Walking Away from the Table
In March 2024, the University of Zurich—one of Europe's premier institutions—announced it would no longer submit its data to THE. Its stated reasons were unequivocal: the ranking "cannot reflect the comprehensive range of activities in teaching and research" across a university, and prioritizing easily quantifiable metrics compels institutions "to focus on increasing the number of publications rather than on improving the quality of their content." A year and a half prior, in November 2022, the dean of Yale Law School, Heather Gerken, withdrew her institution from the U.S. News rankings, describing them as "profoundly flawed": they penalized, she argued, public interest careers, need-based financial aid, and efforts to open the legal profession to working-class students.
The salient detail here should not be overlooked: Yale held the number-one spot in that ranking year after year. This was not a perennial underperformer walking away in frustration; it was the perpetual victor stepping aside. And when the frontrunner refuses to play, the compelling question is no longer who wins, but what game we were actually playing.
What Rankings Actually Do Well
Let us be fair, for caricature is as misguided as blind faith. Rankings are proficient at measuring what they are designed to measure. For a researcher selecting a research group, for an agency allocating grants, or for a doctoral candidate comparing laboratories, citation data and publication volume are valuable and arduous to compile. The flaw lies not within the table, but in how it is interpreted. It stems from mistaking an instrument of research productivity for a verdict on an educational promise—much like evaluating a hospital by its published research rather than by its patient outcomes: publications certainly matter, but they were never the primary promise.
Because your university promised something else entirely. It is articulated in your mission statement, in the solemn language typical of such declarations: holistic education, the whole person, discernment, service. We have noted before that a mission is not merely what is written on a website, and we proposed an uncomfortable exercise: cover the institutional crest and see whether the text remains distinctly yours. Today's exercise is a follow-up. Place your mission statement on one side of the desk. Place the seventeen indicators on the other. And search, with all the goodwill in the world, for the indicator that measures what your mission promises. Take all the time you need: it is simply not there. The table that dictates your public standing does not reflect your founding promise. That asymmetry cannot be remedied by climbing ten spots.
The Mission and the Table
The solution to this disconnect does not lie in dismissing rankings; they will continue to exist and carry weight, not least because families read them, and—as we have observed—when every website sounds identical, the table appears to be the only objective data point. The solution lies in completing the picture: alongside their table, which measures your research, you need your own metric, one that honors the foundational promise. How has this student transformed between their first year and their fourth? Are they more grounded, more discerning, capable of deeper understanding? We also know that 90% of academic leaders consider broad, formative education crucial, yet only 32% believe their students truly grasp it: therein, and not in ranking 165th, lies the true distinction between one university and another.
Within Nomba Excellence's academic pathway, that metric exists and follows a clear methodology: the flourishing of each cohort is assessed at the outset and at the conclusion of the journey, transforming institutional mission from a literary exercise into longitudinal data. It does not replace the ranking; it answers an entirely different question. Theirs asks: how much weight do you carry in the global research arena? Yours asks: how is a person fundamentally shaped by having passed through your halls? The day a parent asks about your position on the table, you will be able to offer that number—and something far more meaningful than the number alone. And that dual answer is something that, as yet, almost no one can provide.
About Us
Discover the school you
never had.
And what if this were your next year?
A journey of ideas, conversations, and twenty minutes a day to continue growing.
The individual
Read the Story
History explains the past; the novel immerses you within it. Trafalgar, War and Peace, The Bridge on the Drina, and Suite Française: why to read them and in what order.
The era
The Greek Professor Who Won the Nobel Prize
The Swedish Academy awards Anne Carson for creating new forms from the classical tradition. Spain saw it first: the Asturias 2020 citation had already said so.
The person
Writing is thinking
The study that banned laptops from classrooms failed to replicate. And yet, writing by hand still matters: the replications, the brain with 256 electrodes, and why writing is thinking.


