Employability in the Age of AI: Hiring for Judgment
Youth employment drops by 13% in positions most exposed to AI, while that of seasoned professionals rises. What protects the latter, and what companies are already demanding: judgment.

Gabriel Serrano

There is a data point that ought to be posted on the door of every university department, and it is not the one featured on the evening news.
In 2025, a Stanford team led by Erik Brynjolfsson—arguably the economist who understands the impact of technology on labor better than anyone—did something unusual: rather than conducting surveys, they examined payrolls. Specifically, those of ADP, the largest payroll processor in the United States. Millions of workers, over seven hundred occupations, one out of every six employees in the country.
What they discovered was not job destruction. Aggregate employment, in fact, continued to grow. What they found was a pair of shears.
Since late 2022, workers aged 22 to 25 in the occupations most exposed to artificial intelligence—customer service, accounting, software development—have seen a 13% decline in relative employment. Their colleagues aged 35 to 40, in the same positions, at the same companies, have experienced growth.
[GRAPHIC: g5-tijera-empleo-joven.png]
Read that again, because it is easy to overlook just how extraordinary it is. The shears do not cut across sectors, as in previous waves of automation. They cut across ages within the same role. Same job, same company: the twenty-five-year-old is no longer hired, while the forty-year-old is.
What does the forty-year-old possess that the twenty-five-year-old lacks?
What the Machine Knows How to Copy
The researchers' answer constitutes the core insight of this article. Young workers compete in the market with what economists term codified knowledge: what is found in lecture notes, in textbooks, in training videos. Whatever can be written down, a machine can learn. And what a machine learns ceases to be scarce.
The forty-year-old, by contrast, brings something else to the table: tacit knowledge. Knowing which client will cause problems before they arise. Knowing which budget cut makes strategic sense and which is merely an impulsive whim. Knowing when a report is genuinely sound and when it merely appears to be. None of this is written down anywhere, and for that reason, as of yet, no machine possesses it.
Nuance matters here, and it is worth presenting in full: part of the 2022 decline coincided with interest rate hikes and the hangover from pandemic-era overhiring, and the Stanford economists themselves debate how much can be attributed to AI in those early months. Yet by 2024, with adoption already widespread, the pattern solidified and accelerated, and it has since been replicated with other datasets in both the United States and the United Kingdom. The trajectory is clear, even if the precise allocation of causes remains subject to debate: the market value of codified knowledge is falling. Which happens to be precisely the type of value with which a recent graduate stepped out to compete.
What Job Postings Now Demand
If the story ended there, it would merely be disheartening. But there is a second half to it, and it can be found in the job postings themselves.
Lightcast, which systematically analyzes millions of job listings, published a figure in 2025 that would have sounded like a joke a decade ago: of the ten most sought-after competencies across all sectors, eight are no longer technical. Communication. Critical thinking. Collaboration. Creativity. Leadership. Fully 76% of postings request at least one; nearly half demand three or more.
[GRAPHIC: g6-ofertas-competencias.png]
The World Economic Forum corroborates this from the corporate perspective: seven out of ten companies consider analytical thinking to be the core competency of their workforce, ahead of any technical skill. Furthermore, it estimates that 39% of core skills will have changed before 2030: what you know how to do today becomes obsolete; your capacity for judgment does not.
[GRAPHIC: g7-pensamiento-analitico.png]
There is a third data point, and it is the most counterintuitive of all. Between 2024 and 2025, demand for AI-specific competencies in recruitment processes dropped from 52% to 38%. Not because AI matters less, but because proficiency with it is now taken for granted, much as knowing how to use email came to be assumed. What distinguishes one candidate from another is no longer the ability to operate the tool; it is what they think to do with it.
And when hires fail, it is almost never due to technical shortcomings: according to the Society for Human Resource Management, 89% of unsuccessful hires fail due to human deficiencies—communication, judgment, cultural fit—not for a lack of technical knowledge. One hiring manager out of… rather, 78% of hiring managers admit to having recruited someone technically brilliant who failed in every other regard.
And What About Here?
In Spain, the trend lags behind, yet it points in the exact same direction. Telefónica has stated this institutionally: technology companies will complement technical profiles with humanist backgrounds to advance in robotics and artificial intelligence, and they already detect demand for philosophers and linguists in fields such as digital security and natural language processing. Hybrid profiles—the computational linguist, the AI ethics analyst—have ceased to be conference oddities.
And yet, let us be candid about the uncomfortable fact: Arts and Humanities graduates still exhibit the lowest labor force participation rate of all academic disciplines in Spain. Anyone who tells you that studying philosophy guarantees employment is misleading you.
Yet that was never the premise.
The False Dichotomy
The mistake lies in framing it as a choice: the humanities or the sciences, liberal arts or employability. The data tells a different story.
What Stanford's shears protect is not the philologist over the engineer. It protects those with discernment over those who merely possess lecture notes, regardless of their degree. A technical degree remains the finest educational investment available: it provides depth, and without depth, there is nothing upon which to pass judgment. What has changed is that depth alone is no longer sufficient, because its codifiable component—which is substantial—is becoming cheap.
The profile the market is rewarding is the engineer who writes well. The physician who knows how to explain. The economist who distinguishes an argument from a slogan. The developer who realizes what is actually worth building. A degree plus discernment. Depth plus interdisciplinary breadth.
Such a profile cannot be improvised in a weekend seminar, nor is it acquired by watching motivational videos. It is cultivated as it always has been: by reading those who thought best, debating with others, and writing until one finds an authentic voice. That is to say: through the humanities. Not instead of a degree. On top of it.
What a University Can Certify
The institutional question remains, which is the one that truly matters to those who design curricula.
For decades, higher education has certified codified knowledge: this is precisely what an academic transcript reflects. The problem is that this is precisely what the machine is devaluing. The question the market is posing to the university is not whether its graduates know their subject—that is presumed—but whether they possess that which cannot be found in the lecture notes: judgment, eloquence, and the capacity to synthesize across disciplines.
Enterprises have already begun to search for this on their own, groping in the dark through interviews and group assessments. The university that learns to cultivate and rigorously credential this—through a genuine curriculum, with authentic evaluation, rather than a decorative line on a diploma supplement—will not merely be adding an embellishment to its degrees. It will be certifying the only portion of the academic record whose value is destined to rise.
Cover image generated with artificial intelligence.
About Us
Discover the school you
never had.
Get Nomba Corporate →
A journey of ideas, conversations, and twenty minutes a day to keep growing.

The Humanities Today
The Russian novel teaches about committees what no MBA can ever explain to you.

Applied Philosophy
The week unfolds, everything functions, yet you were not entirely there. The ancients named that way of living millennia ago, and one does not escape it with a checklist of habits.

The Era
Everyone repeats that skills expire in five years. We went looking for the source, and it is nowhere to be found. What does endure, however, is sound judgment: why the university should be a community, not merely an event.

The Era
Youth employment drops by 13% in positions most exposed to AI, while that of seasoned professionals rises. What protects the latter, and what companies are already demanding: judgment.

Cultural Leadership
Technical talent is abundant. A profile with cultural judgment is the scarce asset.