>


>

Everything can be trained; almost nothing alone.

Everything can be trained; almost nothing alone.

A tennis coach inaugurates the academic year at the university. Science qualifies his thesis: practice matters less than you might think, while mentorship matters far more. What is trained, and with whom.

Gabriel Serrano

A Coach in the Auditorium

On September 22, in Alfara del Patriarca, a university opened its academic year in a rather unusual manner. To inaugurate its Excellence Plan—the track that CEU Cardenal Herrera offers to high-achieving students seeking more than what fits within standard coursework—it did not summon a tech guru or a trendy founder. It called upon a tennis coach. Toni Nadal, the man who trained his nephew from childhood to the pinnacle of world sport, delivered the keynote address of the day in the auditorium: “Beyond Success: Self-Demand, Leadership, and Purpose.” Nearly five hundred students from three campuses attended, and the university chartered buses from Castellón and Elche.

The complete lineup speaks volumes about the institution’s spirit. The day was opened by Juan Carlos Valderrama, director of the Excellence Plan; the rector, philosopher Higinio Marín, offered his remarks; and the Vice Rector of Students, Francisco Javier Montañez, brought the event to a close. In between, our co-founder, Javier Roca, spoke with the students; the program announced his talk under a title that reads almost like a blueprint for living: ten rules for doing something worthwhile. To this notebook, which has spent months writing about what a university can become, the scene is of interest for reasons beyond mere proximity. It is compelling because beneath that bill of speakers lies a thesis, and that thesis invites examination.

The Coach’s Thesis

Toni Nadal has achieved something exceptionally rare in professional sports: dedicating decades of his life to a single student. He distilled what he learned into the title of his book: “Everything Can Be Trained.” Framed that way, it might sound like an airport self-help manual, and that is precisely why it warrants serious consideration—for clichés are often the very notions that almost no one bothers to scrutinize. Is it true? Can everything be trained—talent, character, excellence—or are some born to achieve while others are destined merely to watch?

Psychology had spent decades turning that question over when the Swedish psychologist K. Anders Ericsson studied violinists at the Berlin University of the Arts and proposed the answer that achieved widespread fame: what separates the very good from the merely good is years of deliberate practice. Not just any repetition: the uncomfortable kind, designed precisely to target what one cannot yet do, paired with immediate correction and no mercy for the comfort zone. Popular science transformed this into the ten-thousand-hour rule, a tidy figure that Ericsson himself spent half a lifetime qualifying. There was never a magic number. The key lay not in the noun “hours,” but in the adjective.

The Fine Print That Seems to Refute the Book

In this publication, data is presented alongside its history and its counterarguments, so here is the counterargument. In 2014, three researchers—Brooke Macnamara, David Hambrick, and Frederick Oswald—published in Psychological Science the most widely cited meta-analysis on the subject: 88 studies and over eleven thousand individuals evaluated. Their conclusion can be summed up in their own words: deliberate practice is important, but not nearly as important as had been argued. On average, hours of practice accounted for roughly 14% of the variance in performance between individuals. In games, music, and sports, considerably more. Yet upon reaching education and the professions—which is to say, the everyday lives of nearly everyone—the figure plummeted almost to the floor.

Read hastily, the meta-analysis appears to dismantle Toni Nadal’s title: if practice accounts for so little, then everything cannot be trained. It pays to read it closely, however, for what that 14% leaves out is not a genetic mystery. It is, in large part, a measurement problem.

The Variable Averages Fail to See

When a meta-analysis aggregates 88 studies, it lumps together practices that bear no resemblance to one another. The person practicing scales alone in a bedroom and the person who has someone standing in front of them—observing, correcting, and redesigning the plan each week—log the exact same hours. Subsequent research has pinpointed that very flaw: by ignoring individualization—the tailored suit—averages underestimate the yields of well-mentored practice. It is here that Toni Nadal’s biography ceases to be a sporting anecdote and becomes the pure case study: one coach, one student, daily calibration over decades, and no excuses. His regimen was never ten thousand hours off the shelf.

This notebook has already reported two findings that point in the same direction. Gallup found that barely 22% of college graduates recall having had a mentor who encouraged them to pursue their goals, and that those who also recall a professor who inspired them and another who cared about them are more than twice as likely to be engaged at work. Furthermore, the largest meta-analysis on character education, encompassing over three hundred thousand participants, found superior outcomes in programs that included mentorship. The underlying conclusion is less epic than the ten-thousand-hour rule, yet considerably more useful: perhaps not everything can be trained, but vastly more can be trained than we typically attempt. And almost none of it alone.

When a University Truly Believes It

That is why the events of September 22 matter, and not merely as a society note. An excellence plan is a university declaring out loud that excellence does not arrive pre-packaged from home with an entrance exam score; rather, it is forged along the way: research, culture, languages, leadership, personal development, over and above standard coursework. We have already written here that an institution’s ethos is not what appears on its website; ethos is what can be pointed to on the calendar. A philosopher-rector addressing the assembly before a tennis coach, before nearly five hundred students from three campuses, is precisely ethos made manifest on the calendar. It is not the only university working in this direction, and may the trend spread. Yet the choice to open the academic year with that conversation—effort, purpose, self-demand—rather than a lecture on industry trends possesses an intentionality that is not lost on the students.

Each Person's Cathedral

There is a screen in the first stage of the journey that explains why this conversation resonates so deeply with us: from a very young age, we have been trained to be productive, never contemplative. The standard of demand lacking in the average student is not the demand to produce faster; that comes factory-installed, and not always without a toll. What is missing is the other kind, the one that the third stage draws from Aristotle: habits make you, and virtue lies in the mean: “it sounds like a calendar aphorism. It is not.” A screen in the sixth stage captures it in three sentences that a tennis coach would endorse without altering a single comma: integrity is trained in small increments. One act today. Another tomorrow. That is how character is built.

And then there is the question the journey poses upon reaching the medieval cathedrals, perhaps the most serious question one can put to a university student: what is the cathedral of your life—that endeavor which would justify an entire lifetime of patience, effort, and meaning? Toni Nadal framed it in his own way in the title of his lecture: beyond success. Javier Roca, in his: something worthwhile. It is the same question with two distinct inflections, and no single tool will answer it for you on its own.

The journey of TheNomba is, fundamentally, our way of training that answer: twelve stages, one virtue per stage, a mentor who calibrates the plan, and a community that does not leave you alone with your good intentions. “Everything can be trained,” reads Toni Nadal’s book. Almost nothing alone, we submit. Between those two sentences, an entire university finds its place.

Cover image generated with artificial intelligence.


About Us


Discover the school you
never had.

Get Nomba Corporate →


What if this were your next year?


What if this were your next year?


What if this were your next year?


A journey of ideas, conversations, and twenty minutes a day to keep growing.


Continue reading


Continue reading


Continue reading

The Humanities Today

Tolstoy in a Business Meeting: Why Literature Develops Better Executives

Tolstoy in a Business Meeting: Why Literature Develops Better Executives

Tolstoy in a Business Meeting: Why Literature Develops Better Executives

The Russian novel teaches about committees what no MBA can ever explain to you.

Applied Philosophy

The Adult on Autopilot

The Adult on Autopilot

The Adult on Autopilot

The week unfolds, everything functions, yet you were not entirely there. The ancients named that way of living millennia ago, and one does not escape it with a checklist of habits.

The Era

Your degree expires; your judgment does not

Your degree expires; your judgment does not

Your degree expires; your judgment does not

Everyone repeats that skills expire in five years. We went looking for the source, and it is nowhere to be found. What does endure, however, is sound judgment: why the university should be a community, not merely an event.

The Era

Employability in the Age of AI: Hiring for Judgment

Employability in the Age of AI: Hiring for Judgment

Employability in the Age of AI: Hiring for Judgment

Youth employment drops by 13% in positions most exposed to AI, while that of seasoned professionals rises. What protects the latter, and what companies are already demanding: judgment.

Cultural Leadership

The Leader Companies Can No Longer Find: Profile and Why It Is in Short Supply

The Leader Companies Can No Longer Find: Profile and Why It Is in Short Supply

The Leader Companies Can No Longer Find: Profile and Why It Is in Short Supply

Technical talent is abundant. A profile with cultural judgment is the scarce asset.

This site uses cookies
We use cookies to enhance your experience, measure performance, and personalize content. Cookie Policy