Virtue is cultivated
Socrates asked whether virtue can be taught. 214 studies and 300,000 participants later, the answer is yes—with three conditions that almost no one meets.

Gabriel Serrano

The question opens one of the oldest dialogues we preserve. Meno, a young aristocrat passing through Athens, asks Socrates point-blank: Can virtue be taught? Or is it acquired through practice? Or does it come by nature? Twenty-four centuries later, we are still debating the same question—only now, for the first time, we have data.
It is fitting to begin with the answer given by that school’s finest pupil, for time has vindicated him in ways even he could not have anticipated. Aristotle argued in the Nicomachean Ethics that ethical virtue arises from habit—and he was fond of noting that in Greek the two words, ethos and ēthikē, are nearly identical. No one is born just or courageous. One becomes just by practicing justice, and courageous by practicing courage, just as a lyre player becomes a lyre player by playing the lyre. Virtue is neither a natural talent nor a syllabus: it is a second nature, and second natures are forged through repetition, over time, and with someone standing before us to offer correction.
Observe what Aristotle described without setting out to do so: content, practice, duration, mentor. The specifications of a curriculum.
The Century That Washed Its Hands
Throughout most of history, universities took that curriculum as their own. Shaping character was not an extracurricular pursuit: it was the very point. The word itself betrays this—formation, to give form to someone, not merely to fill them.
The twentieth century altered the terms of the agreement. For reasons that were by no means frivolous, to be sure: pluralistic societies, fresh memories of indoctrination, respect for individual conscience. The university determined that character was a private matter—belonging to the family, the parish, the individual—and concentrated on what it knew how to measure: knowledge. The result was an institution magnificent in its own domain and mute in all else. It could certify that its graduate understood thermodynamics; as to whether that graduate was capable of keeping their word, it had nothing to say. Nor did it wish to.
The retreat appeared prudent. What no one anticipated was the cost of leaving the field vacant, for the character of young people did not cease to be formed when the university withdrew. Something else began to shape it: the algorithm, the peer group, inertia. The question was never character or no character. It was always who forms it, and with what.
Birmingham and Oxford
In 2012, the University of Birmingham decided that this retreat had lasted too long and founded the Jubilee Centre for Character and Virtues, today the world's premier center of reference in the field. Its founding principles are worth quoting, for they dismantle, one by one, the customary misgivings. Virtues are present in all great traditions, yet they belong to no single religion. Character can be taught, learned, and reinforced, and it ought to be at the heart of education. And educating character does not constrain the young person: it empowers them—it grants them the judgment to make sound decisions about their own life, which is the very opposite of deciding it for them.
Upon this foundation, they built a framework of openly Aristotelian inspiration—habituation as the path, phronesis or practical wisdom as the virtue that governs the rest—now used by hundreds of schools across four continents. And in 2020, together with the Oxford Character Project, they extended it to our area of concern with a report on character education in universities whose diagnosis we have previously recounted here: nearly all universities promise character qualities in their graduate profiles; very few possess a method. Even university rankings have taken note—four questions on growth in wisdom, justice, and contribution to society were incorporated into the Wall Street Journal’s college rankings through that very Oxford project.
In short, serious conversation about virtue no longer takes place on the self-help shelf. It takes place in Birmingham and Oxford.
What the Evidence Says—and Its Fine Print
There remains Meno’s question in its unsparing form: Does it work?
In 2023, the Journal of Moral Education published the largest meta-analysis ever conducted on character education programs: 214 studies, over three hundred thousand participants. The overall result is positive and statistically robust, with a modest effect size—in the field's parlance, a g of 0.24. Modest is not trivial: it is on par with what is achieved by educational interventions we deem valuable. But the real headline is not the average. It is the moderators, the conditions that distinguish programs that move the needle from those that do not.
The first condition has a proper name: mentor. Programs featuring formal mentorship yielded greater effects than those without it. The authors add the crucial nuance: trained mentors, rigorous follow-up, clearly defined objectives. Ambient good example is not enough; there must be a specific person attending to a specific person.
The second condition emerges when looking at which formats yield the greatest returns: the guided discussion of dilemmas and case studies—the ancient method of conversing about difficult things—multiplies the effect of passive formats. The values poster in the lobby, as we all suspected, does not feature among the winners.
And the fine print, which is always recounted here: effects decay over time once the program concludes—from 0.26 upon completion to 0.17 at follow-up—and the published literature exhibits selection bias, so the adjusted estimate is lower, though it remains positive and significant. Read carefully what this decay signifies, for it is not an argument against character education. It is an argument against weekend workshops. Virtue, like muscle, responds to training and atrophies without it: precisely what Aristotle said of habit. Effects endure when the program endures.
The Three Conditions
Bring all the preceding together, and the entire field fits into a single sentence: virtue is trained, provided that training entails conversation about reality, a named mentor, and years ahead.
Three conditions. All three uncomfortable, because all three come at a cost: conversation demands small groups and fine texts; mentorship demands training and faculty time; years demand an itinerary where nearly the entire sector offers quick fixes. That is why shortcuts abound—the motivational talk, the framed creed, the values week—and that is why shortcuts appear in meta-analyses as nothing more than the control group.
One Virtue per Stage
A serious humanities curriculum takes these three conditions to heart, and adds a fourth that derives directly from Aristotle: virtue is not taught in the abstract; it is taught embodied.
That is why each stage of the journey addresses a virtue within its own subject matter, not as an annexed sermon. Fortitude is learned through history—with real people who endured real trials. Temperance, by reconnecting with nature and with that which an empty heart attempts to purchase. Prudence, through philosophy; audacity, in the final stage, when the time comes to launch an endeavor alongside others before stepping out the door. Twelve stages, twelve virtues, an in-house professor guiding the conversation, and years—not a weekend.
Socrates, for that matter, never gave Meno a definitive answer; the dialogue concludes, as do nearly all of his, with the question sharper than at the outset. Perhaps that was the lesson. Virtue can indeed be taught—yet it cannot be dictated. It is conversed, practiced, and caught, beside someone who already possesses it. Now the data confirms it. He did so every morning in the agora.
Cover image generated with artificial intelligence.
About Us
Discover the school you
never had.
Get Nomba Corporate →
A journey of ideas, conversations, and twenty minutes a day to keep growing.

The Humanities Today
The Russian novel teaches about committees what no MBA can ever explain to you.

Applied Philosophy
The week unfolds, everything functions, yet you were not entirely there. The ancients named that way of living millennia ago, and one does not escape it with a checklist of habits.

The Era
Everyone repeats that skills expire in five years. We went looking for the source, and it is nowhere to be found. What does endure, however, is sound judgment: why the university should be a community, not merely an event.

The Era
Youth employment drops by 13% in positions most exposed to AI, while that of seasoned professionals rises. What protects the latter, and what companies are already demanding: judgment.

Cultural Leadership
Technical talent is abundant. A profile with cultural judgment is the scarce asset.